The Mental Shift Nobody Talks About
- Stephanie McKibban

- Jan 2
- 3 min read
When Competing Builds Your Confidence… and Tests It at the Same Time
When people think about competing, they usually think about abs, heels, spray tans, and maybe the moment you step on stage pretending you’re not absolutely aware of every muscle fiber in your body.
What they don’t talk about enough is what happens between your ears.
Because somewhere between your lifestyle routine and your first prep timeline, your confidence does something weird.
It grows.
And then it gets poked.
Sometimes on the same day.
Welcome to the mental shift nobody warns you about.
Confidence Grows Because You’re Doing Hard Things on Purpose
One of the first mental changes people notice in prep is a deep sense of pride.
You’re not guessing anymore.
You’re not winging it.
You’re not “kind of” showing up.
You’re following through. Repeatedly. On purpose.
Y
ou hit workouts even when you’re tired.
You plan meals like it’s a logistical sport.
You stop negotiating with yourself every five minutes.
And suddenly, confidence shows up quietly like, “Huh… I can actually rely on myself.”
This isn’t hype confidence.
It’s earned confidence.
The kind that comes from keeping promises to yourself.
And for a lot of lifestyle clients, this is brand new territory.
Then Confidence Gets Challenged When Your Body Becomes the Assignment
Here’s where things shift.
In a lifestyle phase, your body is something you improve.
In prep, your body becomes something you present.
Now it’s:
Front pose
Back pose
Side pose
Lighting
Angles
Feedback
Your body isn’t just yours anymore. It’s part of the job.
And even confident people can feel a little exposed when the conversation moves from “I feel strong” to “Here’s what needs work.”
That doesn’t mean prep is damaging.
It means prep is honest.
You Learn the Difference Between Feeling Good About Yourself and Trusting Yourself
This is a big one.
Self-esteem is how you feel about yourself.
Self-trust is knowing you’ll show up even when feelings change.
Prep builds self-trust fast.
Self-esteem? That one fluctuates.
Some days you feel unstoppable.
Other days you feel like your quads disappeared overnight (they didn’t, but prep brain says they did).
The win isn’t feeling confident all the time.
The win is learning you don’t fall apart when confidence wobbles.
Comparison Hits Differently During Prep
Lifestyle comparison usually sounds like,
“Oh, she looks great. Good for her.”
Prep comparison sounds more like,“Why doesn’t my glute tie-in look like that?”
“Am I behind?”
“Do I even belong here?”
And here’s the truth nobody wants to admit:
Comparison doesn’t mean you’re insecure.It means you care.
The skill you build in prep is learning to use comparison for information, not self-worth.
Which is easier said than done. Especially on social media. Especially at peak week.
Feedback Becomes a Confidence Upgrade (Eventually)
Prep introduces you to feedback that has nothing to do with effort.
Y
ou can do everything right and still hear:
“Needs more upper body”
“Needs more time”
“Needs more development”
At first, that can sting.
Then something powerful happens.
You realize:
Feedback isn’t failure
Being unfinished doesn’t mean you’re unworthy
You can be proud and a work in progress
That’s grown confidence. Not fragile confidence.
The Weird Paradox: You Feel Stronger and More Vulnerable at the Same Time
This is the part people never post about.
You feel:
Mentally tougher
More disciplined
Proud of your consistency
And also:
More sensitive
More aware of imperfections
Slightly emotionally exposed
Both are normal.
Both can exist.
Neither means you’re “not cut out for this.”
It means you’re stretching beyond your comfort zone.
And This Is Why Competing Isn’t for Everyone (And That’s Not a Bad Thing)
This mental shift is powerful, but it’s optional.
Some people thrive in it.
Some people decide lifestyle goals support their confidence better.
Some compete once and say, “I’m glad I did it, and I’m glad I don’t need to do it again.”
All valid.
The real win isn’t the stage.
It’s understanding yourself better through the process.
FINAL THOUGHT
Prep doesn’t just change your body.
It introduces you to parts of your confidence you’ve never had to meet before.
Whether you step on stage or stay lifestyle, the growth comes from doing things intentionally, not accidentally.
And that kind of confidence?
That sticks long after the tan fades.




Comments